sockwithaticket wrote: ↑Sat Jun 11, 2022 7:55 pm
La Rochelle not looking like a team who just won the European Cup, Toulouse well on top.
Pretty dull watching. Too fractured with high error count: esp from LaR. Not helped by the assinine commentators on Premier.
Once again, Dupont is the key difference.
Ironic that Toulouse did to LaR what LaR did to Leinster i.e. ran rush defence out wide the entire game to force the runners back into the traffic. West is so dogsh*t awful, he was never going to have the kicking or running game to alter the method of attack.
If the Toulon fans are up in arms about Carbonel going, wait until they get to see a few West performance.
Yes, big gamble by Urios but the performance of the team against USAP was not acceptable. Jalibert is not performing to the level you would expect him to. Bègles unlocked the game yesterday through tries that did not involve him. The lad has a huge ego.
I hope the team and Urios can fix things as it would be a pity for this club if they did not.
Yeah. That is massively disappointing and player rebellion is nothing new. Especially in France. Increasingly we are seeing this in rugby as money and media exposure increases. Funny how FHs figure a lot in this e.g. Russell.
I assume you both read Jalibert's disgraceful response? If I were in Urios's position, I'd have him out of the door. Also, I can't imagine Galthie is going to tolerate such sh*t and Jalibert may have shot himself in the foot. Galthie is not like Villepreux/Skrela or Lievremont.
In a couple of interviews Urios said that Jalibert was “orgueilleux”and that was one of his great qualities, it looks like he’s having a big head now, same for Woki.
Urios was right to be piss of with them, Woki has done nothing since the 6N, but it could be the coach’s fault as they put him in 4 & 8 most of the time, and Jalibert seemed to preserve himself for the Japan trip.
Hopefully everything will be fine for 22/23, but now I’m not sure that Cameron will extend his contract with Bordeaux.
In a couple of interviews Urios said that Jalibert was “orgueilleux”and that was one of his great qualities, it looks like he’s having a big head now, same for Woki.
Urios was right to be piss of with them, Woki has done nothing since the 6N, but it could be the coach’s fault as they put him in 4 & 8 most of the time, and Jalibert seemed to preserve himself for the Japan trip.
Hopefully everything will be fine for 22/23, but now I’m not sure that Cameron will extend his contract with Bordeaux.
Yes: thin line between pride and arrogance. I'm not even sure you can have one without the other in sport.
Woki may be suffering from too much rugby as well as the positional shuffling. He has certainly been less prominent around the park but his lineout work remains crucial for France. Backrow is looking interesting and not in a good way
- Woki as discussed: even if he is in the backrow
- Ollivon was looking every bit the player of the past... right up until the 2 games that mattered: Lyon and Racing.
- Macalou is still in the doghouse.
- Cros puts in loads of tackles but offers little else.
- Jelonch has been Mr Invisible through much of the 6N. Toulouse's amount of ball they turn over in possession remains a terrifying statistic when 2/3rds of France's backrow is there.
- Clermont have ruined nearly every player including Iturria. Only Penaud has survived the decline.
TheFrog wrote: ↑Mon Jun 13, 2022 10:34 pm
Haddad coming to the rescue as the mobile backrow forward we need.
Mobility really isn't an issue with any of the ones listed and I excluded Le Roux and Lauret from that (both are gone from Galthie's mind and Le Roux is better at lock anyway).
For me, the problems are
- lack of lineout options.
- lack of ability to slow opposition ball and turn it over: most of this work is done by non backrow players such as Marchand, Dupont, Danty & Villiere but those guys can only do that when play hits their sectors. They cannot come to the breakdowns to do the jobs the backrow consistently fails to do.
- lack of consistency. All of the players in that list have shone at some time (some more than others) but getting a unit that works together and is in form at the same time is defeating France. Ironically, having to many options is hampering the process: other teams just have to pick what is available.
but getting a unit that works together and is in form at the same time is defeating France.
Hmmm. The have beaten every single opposition they faced at least once in the last 12 months.
The backrow played a major role in this run of victories.
No. It really did not. The backrow tackled like demons (mostly: where Jelonch was for some of the games was a mystery) but it terms of slowing or turning over ball, Aldritt was a one man band. France simply had a better team across the park but I fear what might happen against SA, for example.
but getting a unit that works together and is in form at the same time is defeating France.
Hmmm. The have beaten every single opposition they faced at least once in the last 12 months.
The backrow played a major role in this run of victories.
No. It really did not. The backrow tackled like demons (mostly: where Jelonch was for some of the games was a mystery) but it terms of slowing or turning over ball, Aldritt was a one man band. France simply had a better team across the park but I fear what might happen against SA, for example.
You are picking the only team they have not played against as a source of worry., discounting the rest of their season. Why not.
And yes, the BR played a central role in this run of victories. 6/7 players will be competing for a place and that's good for the team.
If anything, we are thin in the second row & tight head, but certainly not in the back 3 unit.
La soule wrote: ↑Wed Jun 15, 2022 9:15 am
If anything, we are thin in the second row & tight head, but certainly not in the back 3 unit.
TH, FB and FH are all a headache.
No problem** with locks really. If going for the tried and tested "1 lump + 1 athlete", despite my qualification reservations, Willemse is as good a lump as any on the planet........ although he is the only real candidate and I hope that knee isn't serious. Jedrasiak had looked the part too until ASM managed to ruin him.
In terms of mobiles: Le Roux, Woki, Itrurria (caveat on ASM again^^) are all good operators.
** Because I would not be adverse to 2 mobile locks as long as there was enough weight in the backrow to compensate.
Faumina back for ST but Cros gone, replaced by Placines, on the bench. Fouyssac had finally a good game last week and cold start to deliver. If he does, ST by 10.
Faumina back for ST but Cros gone, replaced by Placines, on the bench. Fouyssac had finally a good game last week and cold start to deliver. If he does, ST by 10.
I like your confidence given ST's recent form against CO.
Faumina back for ST but Cros gone, replaced by Placines, on the bench. Fouyssac had finally a good game last week and cold start to deliver. If he does, ST by 10.
I like your confidence given ST's recent form against CO.
ST are picking at the right time and I think that even if CO is at its most annoying self, ST will be a level up.
Tichtheid wrote: ↑Fri Jun 17, 2022 7:35 pm
Just joined the game to see Arnold smack the Castres player square in the face.
I have no idea why that isn't a red card
Because it's Toulouse against a minnow and T14 reffing is totally bent in such situations. Ref tried desperately to ignore it until it came up on the big screen.
Torquemada 1420 wrote: ↑Fri Jun 17, 2022 7:53 pm
F**king ridiculous. Marchand should be redded for arguing with the ref. Instead, the ref agrees to go to the TMO. Who the f**k is reffing this game?
I don't like the law but I think the ref got that wrong, he played the arm first, not the ball