Worst Commentators/Pundits

[And 1 guest]

Miles Harrison, Jiffy, Barnes, Andy Nicholl.
Admiral Lord Botham, Nick Knight
All hysterical football commentators

[sockwithaticket]

Best would be a much shorter list.

You can't bring up Harrison and not Barnes.

Also - Guscott and Woodward.
Lesser offenders - Dallaglio and Monye, both spout some utterly gormless rubbish during Prem games.

[And 1 guest]

Barnes is there. Ackford is up for discussion.
BOD and Greenwood

[dkm57]

Worst - Barnes with Jiffy just behind

Best of all time by a loooong way - Bill McLaren

[notfatcat]

Dowie Morris is comfortably worse than Barnes or Harrison.

[Hugo]

Best of all time by a loooong way - Bill McLaren

Indeed.

I enjoy listening to the Kiwi commentators in general. Keith Quinn and Murray Mexted were my favs.

[sorCrer]

Bob Skinstad

[Caley_Red]

Best across any sport is Michael Johnson, superb analyst and commentator.

Best in rugby: Andrew Cotter.

Worst in rugby: Jiffy and Alphonso

[Munch]

Worst - Barnes with Jiffy just behind

Best of all time by a loooong way - Bill McLaren

This, but not this. Jiffy is a legend and anyone who thinks otherwise is just jealous that he's not rooting for their team.

[sockwithaticket]

Worst - Barnes with Jiffy just behind

Best of all time by a loooong way - Bill McLaren

This, but not this. Jiffy is a legend and anyone who thinks otherwise is just jealous that he's not rooting for their team.

Jiffy has one of the most annoying voices in broadcasting and serves up commentary weaker than some random pisshead propping up the bar. He and all the geriatric BBC crew need to be cut loose. That said he was good value on House of Rugby, if he could bring a bit more of that to his commentary he'd maybe get a chance to redeem himself.

[Yr Alban]

Andy Nicol is a crap pundit and embarrassingly one-eyed, but given that this appears to be the norm nowadays, I won’t apologise for him.

[Guy Smiley]

It’s Phil Kearns...

by the length of the straight.

[Chilli]

The Welsh person with the squeaky high pitched voice, most of the Aussies, the Kiwi "chick", Warren Brosnihan and Bob Skinstad.

[FujiKiwi]

Grant Nisbett always mixes up Māori and Polynesian players.

“And Patrick Tuipulotu scores a wonderful, length-of-the-field try! Great try Patrick Tuipulotu!”

(After third replay) “Oh, wait sorry, it’s Sevu Reece”

The other thing that gets my goat about Nisbett is how he only ever comments on one thing: pace. “Rieko Ioane, showing his pace! Wait, no, sorry, it’s Mark Telea, is it?”

Honestly, “pace” is the only thing he notices.

[Ymx]

It’s Phil Kearns...

by the length of the straight.

How did so many posts occur, and this is his first mention.

https://www.change.org/p/fox-sports-sac ... entary-box

[FujiKiwi]

Not the worst broadcaster, but for me the most painful moment on TV was after the 2011 RWC final, interviewer Ian Smith went up to losing captain Thierry Dusautoir and addressed him on camera as “Thierry Henry”.

[Guy Smiley]

Grant Nisbett always mixes up Māori and Polynesian players.

“And Patrick Tuipulotu scores a wonderful, length-of-the-field try! Great try Patrick Tuipulotu!”

(After third replay) “Oh, wait sorry, it’s Sevu Reece”

The other thing that gets my goat about Nisbett is how he only ever comments on one thing: pace. “Rieko Ioane, showing his pace! Wait, no, sorry, it’s Mark Telea, is it?”

Honestly, “pace” is the only thing he notices.

Not the only thing... locks are always big lock forwards. Big.

Big lock forward.

[Zig]

George Hook

End of thread.

[Demilich]

There are so many bad ones (and not just confined to rugby - the NRL is even worse).

I always hated Keith Quinn growing up, but it's gotten to the point I would almost accept him back.

If I had to choose one that grinds my gears, it would probably be Willie Lose.

[-RB-]

Sumo Stevenson should take a long walk off a short plank.

[FujiKiwi]

As an interviewer, Jeff Wilson asks a question and then gives a long-winded answer himself, leaving the interviewee with nothing to say.

[Guy Smiley]

Jesus... how could I forget?

Justin Marshall.

Boomfa

[Slick]

The wimmin

[-RB-]

The wimmin

That English bird in the cricket is quite good.

[Jimmy Smallsteps]

Grant Nisbett always mixes up Māori and Polynesian players.

“And Patrick Tuipulotu scores a wonderful, length-of-the-field try! Great try Patrick Tuipulotu!”

(After third replay) “Oh, wait sorry, it’s Sevu Reece”

The other thing that gets my goat about Nisbett is how he only ever comments on one thing: pace. “Rieko Ioane, showing his pace! Wait, no, sorry, it’s Mark Telea, is it?”

Honestly, “pace” is the only thing he notices.

Not the only thing... locks are always big lock forwards. Big.

Big lock forward.

I think it's time for Nisbo to enjoy his retirement.

Aside from this, he often gets ref's calls wrong that are in plain sight for the viewer.

[Ref motions for knock on]

Oh wow! Penalty! Woah that's a bug ducusion! Lets see if they'll go for goal from here!...oh no, wait...no, it's a knock on.

[Jimmy Smallsteps]

As an interviewer, Jeff Wilson asks a question and then gives a long-winded answer himself, leaving the interviewee with nothing to say.

I don't mind Wilson as a commentator / pundit but does he have to be so fucking serious? He seems to be a very intense man.

I'd love to see him lighten up and rip the absolute piss out of someone.

[SaintK]

Worst - Barnes with Jiffy just behind

Best of all time by a loooong way - Bill McLaren

This, but not this. Jiffy is a legend and anyone who thinks otherwise is just jealous that he's not rooting for their team.

Jiffy has one of the most annoying voices in broadcasting and serves up commentary weaker than some random pisshead propping up the bar. He and all the geriatric BBC crew need to be cut loose. That said he was good value on House of Rugby, if he could bring a bit more of that to his commentary he'd maybe get a chance to redeem himself.

Shane Williams not far behind on the annoying stakes and a dreadful analyst.

[Slick]

The wimmin

That English bird in the cricket is quite good.

I was being a bit tongue in cheek as there are some great female commentators and pundits - Alex Scott on Match of the Day is brilliant. But I have to say I can't stand the woman cricket one, I can't listen to it.

Also, Maggie Alphonsi is rubbish.

[Yeeb]

Commentators - don’t mind most of them, but do miss Nigel Starmer smith who was my preferred commentator even above Bill McLaren, who was great but used to get certain names wrong (eg Martin Johnston).

Don’t mind jiffy and his insane “Numbers !” Call outs. Prefer Brian Moore though, especially when he gets so mad and you hear him rip off his headset.

SA have this awful droning chap, Hugh blaydon? Awful voice - irish have another droning chap whose name I forget.

Pundits - they are all pretty shit, I don’t mind dewi Morris but it’s amazing how one eyed certain ex players can be, or how boring (Nicol, Lol, castagne, any saffa, Bod)

Worst was Phil vickery, said nothing then “ that - is - a - scrummmmmmmmm”

[Monkey Magic]

Jesus... how could I forget?

Justin Marshall.

Boomfa

The messed up thing is that in between his micro skills and yes boy! He actually puts out some great analysis on how things play out / why defenders ended up in no man's land. It limited but far better than a lot of others.

Nisbetts time should be done, remember one game where Kaino had one of the greatest games of all time, he carried the ball somehow got out of the ruck then carried again, to then get out of that ruck and carry down the wing, turn the ball over and put in a thumping tackle on the other side of the field.

The most amazing thing is he did all this while sitting in the stands injured

[Un Pilier]

The wimmin

That English bird in the cricket is quite good.

I was being a bit tongue in cheek as there are some great female commentators and pundits - Alex Scott on Match of the Day is brilliant. But I have to say I can't stand the woman cricket one, I can't listen to it.

Also, Maggie Alphonsi is rubbish.

Woman cricket one? Isa Guha or Ebony Rainford-Brent? Or Alison Mitchell? All very good imo.

[Not_Couch]

Whoever that dreadful English prick that commentated the 2015 RWC final.


Then Phil Kearns

[handyman]

NZ - Enjoyed Nisbett, but time to go I think. TJ is good value.
Aus - Sh1t, all of them, even Kafer.
SA - Pearce is good, Stransky and Shimange as well. Nkumane, Capastagn horrible.
The Welsh commentator with the awful voice, sh1t.

[sockwithaticket]

This, but not this. Jiffy is a legend and anyone who thinks otherwise is just jealous that he's not rooting for their team.

Jiffy has one of the most annoying voices in broadcasting and serves up commentary weaker than some random pisshead propping up the bar. He and all the geriatric BBC crew need to be cut loose. That said he was good value on House of Rugby, if he could bring a bit more of that to his commentary he'd maybe get a chance to redeem himself.

Shane Williams not far behind on the annoying stakes and a dreadful analyst.

I find him more torpor inducing, which is a different sphere of awful also inhabited by Phil Vickery whose flirtation with commentary seems to have been blessedly brief.

[Begbie]

Shane Williams is terrible and dull as fuck. I don't mind Jiffy when he does the rugby league.

[Woddy]

That English bird in the cricket is quite good.

I was being a bit tongue in cheek as there are some great female commentators and pundits - Alex Scott on Match of the Day is brilliant. But I have to say I can't stand the woman cricket one, I can't listen to it.

Also, Maggie Alphonsi is rubbish.

Woman cricket one? Isa Guha or Ebony Rainford-Brent? Or Alison Mitchell? All very good imo.

Mitchell and Guha are both very good, don't know ERB. TMS team is generally pretty strong at the moment. Carlos is great for WI stuff - think I missed him reading out the Shipping Forecast unfortunately. Botham is the very worst for cricket; just the fact that people have to use his titles. What a tit.

On rugby, I'm a secret Jiffy fan. At least he shows his passion for the game - you can hear his sighs and groans even when he's trying to keep off-mic. Same with BCM. Guscott should be taken out the back and shot, along with LBND, Woodward and BOD. Barnes should be shot before going out the back, on live TV preferably. Wilko's fine, but sounds a little bored. Jiffy Jnr was pretty good last season.

[Woddy]

That English bird in the cricket is quite good.

I was being a bit tongue in cheek as there are some great female commentators and pundits - Alex Scott on Match of the Day is brilliant. But I have to say I can't stand the woman cricket one, I can't listen to it.

Also, Maggie Alphonsi is rubbish.

Woman cricket one? Isa Guha or Ebony Rainford-Brent? Or Alison Mitchell? All very good imo.

Mitchell and Guha are both very good, don't know ERB. TMS team is generally pretty strong at the moment. Carlos is great for WI stuff - think I missed him reading out the Shipping Forecast unfortunately. Botham is the very worst for cricket; just the fact that people have to use his titles. What a tit.

On rugby, I'm a secret Jiffy fan. At least he shows his passion for the game - you can hear his sighs and groans even when he's trying to keep off-mic. Same with BCM. Guscott should be taken out the back and shot, along with LBND, Woodward and BOD. Barnes should be shot before going out the back, on live TV preferably. Wilko's fine, but sounds a little bored. Jiffy Jnr was pretty good last season.

[-RB-]

That English bird in the cricket is quite good.

I was being a bit tongue in cheek as there are some great female commentators and pundits - Alex Scott on Match of the Day is brilliant. But I have to say I can't stand the woman cricket one, I can't listen to it.

Also, Maggie Alphonsi is rubbish.

Woman cricket one? Isa Guha or Ebony Rainford-Brent? Or Alison Mitchell? All very good imo.

Isa Guha. Pretty tidy into the bargain.

For cricket Danny Morrison is absolute shite.

[RichieRich89]

I like Nisbett and Jiffy.

Nick Mullins and Ryle Nugent I find annoying. Cotter can be mildly irritating sometimes too.

[Margin__Walker]

Another vote for Barnes here.

The absolute worst though (and they have been mentioned) are the pundits that get wheeled out every tournament, despite it being clear they don't actually watch any rugby in their spare time. Woodward and Guscott for a start.

At least you get the impression Jiffy is actually a fan of the game.

Edit - And agree, the TMS ladies are generally very good