-RB- wrote: Thu Sep 10, 2020 12:08 pm
Oh well move on then. Nothing to see here then.
Serious question Fonzee, have you travelled much, specifically to other western developed nations? You are clearly a very smart guy with your finger on the pulse as to what is going on there, people's motivations, historical context, minority background etc I enjoy your informative and insightful posts.
But...
...I don't think you really get just how abhorrent some of us from other first world nations on here view the rampant gun violence, the homelessness, the fucked up healthcare, the prison system, the cost of tertiary education, the lobbying, the opiod epidemic, the covid situation etc etc...
Look it's clearly a great place for the majority but nonetheless it's majorly messed up. It's not just america bashing all the time. It is possible to hold these views and still be thankful the US is around to keep all the bastard regime shitholes in check and be also remain aware of the problems in one's own backyard.
It's a perspective thing and being the US everyone has one.
Traveled plenty around this country, but apart from a dozen or so visits to Quebec in the past few years (got family there now), and my first visit to Europe (Portugal) last year to see my now-expat dad, no. Certainly plan to, definitely would love to, but vacations were mostly for visiting family growing up, and I've been effectively impoverished since I left the nest. God willing, that will change next summer when I graduate and get a proper job.
Anywho, I do understand how many of those things are viewed...I share many of those views myself! And trust me, you won't find an American who doesn't think the nation is majorly messed up -- all that varies is what they consider to be a problem, and correspondingly whether they blame it on rednecks or libs.
Nevertheless, some things I see and hear reflect a cartoon America that doesn't really comport with reality. Take the above example; there is no doubt that there is a massive homeless problem in places like California, really all up and down the West Coast. But an italicized
everywhere (and I'm told we Yanks have trouble with irony and sarcasm, so please set me straight if I'm missing it), suggests that this is ubiquitous. And it's not, not even close. [My pet peeve-est cartoonish disconnect is on race relations; God knows how many fools I've had to smack down for insisting that blacks open-carrying would get lit up like Peter Weller in the opening scene of Robocop. Thankfully the aforementioned and well-named Not Fucking Around Coalition seems to have put that to bed once and for all.]
But let us also look closer at that post (and not taking a shot at you Ali Cadoo, you're just the nearest available source). Our failure to do anything about this is "truly disgusting"; in response to Hugo's post listing our various flaws, I don't think it's a leap to suggest that this is implying a collective moral failing. And I wouldn't say that there's
nothing to that assertion.
But can we be real for one second? We are larger than Germany. The UK. France. Spain. And Italy.
Combined. We are 66x larger than your great nation. Correct me if I'm wrong, but in this day and age we tend to assign moral blame to actors who have control over their (in)actions. Do you all really believe that we can just all get up tomorrow and fix all of these things? Do you believe we can fix
anything?
I guess the tldr version is: we cannot be like your nations. A liberal democracy containing a third of a billion people has never been attempted, and when you think about all the money in play, the diversity (I don't necessarily mean ethnic, but probably that too to a degree), and the realities of information dissemination in the digital age, I don't think I'm being dramatic by saying that the odds are against it working.
It is an audacious project. Cut us some slack.