6 Nations round 5 - Ireland v Scotland

[sockwithaticket]

Not sure there's any separation. Try.

That was my thought. Think the on field decision swung it. If the on field was try I don't think those angles would have been enough to disallow.

[S/Lt_Phillips]

Not sure there's any separation. Try.

Happy to be wrong!

[Raggs]

That's just terrible from Carley. Completely dismissing the suggestion of a knock on until Dickson steps in. Even if is a try it's poor refereeing.

He didn't dismiss it, he just wasn't taking Finn's opinion. He had no sight and asked his AR as he should.

[Blackmac]

That's just terrible from Carley. Completely dismissing the suggestion of a knock on until Dickson steps in. Even if is a try it's poor refereeing.

He didn't dismiss it, he just wasn't taking Finn's opinion. He had no sight and asked his AR as he should.

Not sure about that. His initial suggestion was try and he shut Russell down even though he is entitled to make a point. It looked more like Dickson deciding he had to intervene.

[Big D]

Manshaming for Zander there

[TheNatalShark]

Scotland should get a yellow on next scrum

[Raggs]

That's just terrible from Carley. Completely dismissing the suggestion of a knock on until Dickson steps in. Even if is a try it's poor refereeing.

He didn't dismiss it, he just wasn't taking Finn's opinion. He had no sight and asked his AR as he should.

Not sure about that. His initial suggestion was try and he shut Russell down even though he is entitled to make a point. It looked more like Dickson deciding he had to intervene.

If he'd said on field decision is a try, I'd agree, but he didn't, so he clearly didn't know if it was a try or not and planned on checking.

[Blackmac]

We need to stop celebrating Ireland's mistakes and try to play some rugby of our own.

[Blackmac]

Scotland should get a yellow on next scrum

Why. Who is infringing.

[Blackmac]

He didn't dismiss it, he just wasn't taking Finn's opinion. He had no sight and asked his AR as he should.

Not sure about that. His initial suggestion was try and he shut Russell down even though he is entitled to make a point. It looked more like Dickson deciding he had to intervene.

If he'd said on field decision is a try, I'd agree, but he didn't, so he clearly didn't know if it was a try or not and planned on checking.

Pretty certain he did say it was a try.

[HKCJ]

Manshaming for Zander there

He has been very average for a while now

[Big D]

Penalty for that yet when the ball pinged of Furlongs chest to an Ireland player in front it was just a scrum.

That was a penalty.

[TheNatalShark]

Scotland should get a yellow on next scrum

Why. Who is infringing.

Fagerson should get it on the next shove over, breaking first.

The whole FR is impinging everywhere unfortunately

[OomStruisbaai]

We don't have connection. Keep us up to date

[Blackmac]

Penalty for that yet when the ball pinged of Furlongs chest to an Ireland player in front it was just a scrum.

That was a penalty.

Absolutely no time to react, yet the Irish player was allowed to catch it.

[Uncle fester]

Penalty for that yet when the ball pinged of Furlongs chest to an Ireland player in front it was just a scrum.

That was a penalty.

It's a penalty because the player actively tried to catch the ball.
McCarthy just had the ball bounce into him.

[Blackmac]

POM actually came across from the side there in front of the Ireland ball carrier and took out Scotland defenders before contact.

[charltom]

Penalty for that yet when the ball pinged of Furlongs chest to an Ireland player in front it was just a scrum.

That was a penalty.

Yeah I was surprised by that.

[Blackmac]

Penalty for that yet when the ball pinged of Furlongs chest to an Ireland player in front it was just a scrum.

That was a penalty.

It's a penalty because the player actively tried to catch the ball.
McCarthy just had the ball bounce into him.

What????

[TheNatalShark]

POM actually came across from the side there in front of the Ireland ball carrier and took out Scotland defenders before contact.

Happened a few times this match, particularly when the Irish backs have the ball and doing the clearing.

Need to adjust and do the same tbh

[Sandstorm]

Douchehorn

[Blackmac]

Surely there is no advantage from the knock on there.

[Biffer]

What the fuck was Kinghorn thinking playing that off the ground.

[sockwithaticket]

How many penalty advantages in fairly quick succession was that? At least 3.

[C69]

No advantage for Scotland there

[Uncle fester]

In real time, I thought try but that was held up

[Insane_Homer]

No try, Ireland, kick the 3 FFS.

[S/Lt_Phillips]

Yellow coming, as expected.

But where was the advantage for Larmour's knock on?

[Sandstorm]

In real time, I thought try but that was held up

Me too. Good decision

[Biffer]

Ref doesn’t even know who he’s trying to give the card.

[TheNatalShark]

In real time, I thought try but that was held up

Me too. Good decision

Excellent real time call

[Blackmac]

No advantage for Scotland there

It's ridiculous. Clear knock on and then advantage over after three passes across the pitch.

[C69]

No advantage for Scotland there

It's ridiculous. Clear knock on and then advantage over after three passes across the pitch.

Amazing

[charltom]

Wasn't that held up? he asked facetiously.

[Blackmac]

So reminiscent of the WC game. Barely fired a shot, just trying to survive.

[Sandstorm]

Is Porter a Māori? Terrible hair, loads of tattoos, bloody strong lad?

[Uncle fester]

No advantage for Scotland there

It's ridiculous. Clear knock on and then advantage over after three passes across the pitch.

I'm confused.
Knock on advantage is always over quickly.

[Blackmac]

No advantage for Scotland there

It's ridiculous. Clear knock on and then advantage over after three passes across the pitch.

I'm confused.
Knock on advantage is always over quickly.

Only if you achieve some degree of advantage.

[Mahoney]

Scotland have completely shat the bed this match.

[C69]

lol not even a pen there