Okay, I'll hold my hand up and repeat what I said at the timeOomStruisbaai wrote: Tue Dec 24, 2024 9:20 am United Rugby Boss
https://www.unitedrugby.com/latest/inte ... -ten-years
“That would be when we brought the South African teams in and created the United Rugby Championship,” he declares.
“They have been tremendously successful in terms of performance and attendance, as well as financially and commercially.
“Pretty much anybody you speak to in the league will say they have raised the standard of the competition on and off the field and they will continue to do that.”
Expanding on the financial benefit, he said:
“It’s a game changer. It’s millions.
“More than half our revenue comes from South Africa via television and sponsorship.
“They are also providing more value to EPCR, via Investec’s sponsorship of the Champions Cup.
“It is a huge part of the rugby economy for Europe.”
- Soup was a stitch up for SA perpetuated by Aus who has no viable ntl comp to sustain themselves through the professional era
- whereas both SA and NZ had world class domestic tournies in the CC and Provincial rugby
- NZ bought into the ploy and I can see reasons why, but not for SA who had the most financial clout and were always going to be shafted by the travel
And here we are today. Chickens roosting. Soup over extended itself massively and Aus are f**ked and NPC (still the most enjoyable comp in the world for me) has gates that a Federale side in France would be embarrassed by, CC has been diminished and Soup is just a meaningless bore.
SA in Europe? Made sense once a long time ago: maybe more so at intl level given the time zones.
Now, as for the contentions in that post
1) URC has been such a shambles in its various guises for so many years, I'll leave othesr to judge improving standards. Results in Europe would suggest otherwise.
2) As for economics, I don't doubt SA revenue has helped there but I'm going to dispute the impact on the HEC. I can categorically say SA's presence has brought nothing to the table for the Fre teams. There is nothing in SA's participation for France.