Torquemada 1420 wrote: Sun Sep 11, 2022 6:53 am
_Os_ wrote: Sat Sep 10, 2022 5:39 pm
I'm not "just shouting "it's racist"" though am I. As a South African you learn to not to do that and just keep pressing on. Over multiple posts I first defined the term coconut describing why it was racist, and then described what the political consequences of that type of thinking are in a society, with an example. To make this post in reply to me, you had to ignore my points, you also ignored my questions about the latter part of all that (the inevitable consequences if the thinking you advocate becomes entrenched). Do you think only people that aren't white can be racial traitors if they support the Tories, and within the context of an increasingly multiracial society do you think this thinking somehow won't be applied to whites if it flourishes, that they too will be racial traitors if they support a certain party?
Very funny about not thinking I knew anything about the hostile environment and the Windrush scandal also, despite actually being an African living in the UK. Then ignoring my reply there also. Have you ever completed a Windrush Scheme application for yourself or a relative, do you know what it entails? Ever been to Lunar House and told your case was all to difficult and to basically fuck off?
You're out of your depth.
I'm bored of your JKM weaseling around the subject so will distil this down to 2 simple questions. The answers are binary. YES or NO? No need for 4 paragraphs of obfuscation.
1) Is the Tory party institutionally racist?
2) Do you think you know better than coloured people (black, if you want to narrow it to this particular debate) what is and isn't racist to them?
So you ignored my questions, thought as much.
I'll finish off the stuff on the hostile environment (which you brought up). You mentioned it to make the point that the Tories were to blame for it. But that's not what anyone who has been subjected to the hostile environment (guessing you haven't?), or has actually gone through the Windrush Scheme process themselves or helped a relative through it, would think. I know this because I'm speaking from personal experience. Instead the entire UK state is blamed, not just the Tories alone. The Windrush Scheme process makes it really naked, because all the various seemingly arbitrary cut off dates (if before abc date x applies otherwise y applies) are the dates laws came into force which further stripped people of rights until they were turned into illegal immigrants. These laws span 1949 to1983, under both Tory and Labour governments, a leaked Home Office report admits immigration laws during those 30 years were intentionally designed to limit the UK's non-white population.
Now, if you actually knew what you were talking about you would know this, and the names of all the Acts of Parliament the dates they came into force and what they did (as I do, but you're pleading you struggle with paragraphs). And that all the hostile environment really did was enforce them (by empowering petty officials that don't even understand the laws) and then added to them. Anyway ...
1. I think it's widely known they're an Islamophobic organisation, this is what even some of their reps who are Muslim have said. I'm not going to fight that hard if someone says they're institutionally racist.
2. Black people aren't a monolith, there is no black hive mind. As with white people there's many different views. The ones who get called racial traitors because of their political views, do not regard themselves as being white, they say they are black but you choose to ignore them and I don't. Unintentionally your question shows where you're going wrong, for it to make sense and be answerable the starting point has to be a one size fits all cookie cutter with no deviation, there's no room in your thought for individuals with their own opinions. Not convinced you would treat whites this way, as in something like "Are you against Brexit and therefore against the opinion of the whites and trying to dictate your view to the whites? YES or NO".