The Official Scottish Rugby Thread

[dpedin]

Showed a bit of baws to get back into it. Didn't think they looked too bad from 60 on, more aggressive. Boyle made a difference at the breakdown.

Huge difference. Edinburgh were losing the gainline battle all the way through the first half but Boyle made a couple of great turnovers that stopped any Dragons momentum. I thought the replacement props were much better than the Dragons replacements too.

Agreed (I’ve just watched the second half back now). Boyle made a huge difference at the breakdown. Generally Edinburgh in the last 20 were miles ahead of where they had been in the first 60. The Dragons still butchered a couple of decent chances though. Overall, a vastly unconvincing display from Embra, but it’s an away win and I’d have bitten your hand off for that at HT. Healy deservedly MoM.

Looked like a team who needed a warm up game tbh - too many new faces who didn't play in any warm up games. How did we manage to win that against Dragons who were on top for all of the first half? They can only get better, surely?

[topofthemoon]

Match preview for Glasgow v Leinster:

https://ontopofthemoon.com/2023/10/21/m ... x6eKWVSJRQ

Also, Glasgow are doing a digital match programme this season. Top Of The Moon stats and history of the Glasgow - Leinster fixture on pages 24 and 25:

https://www.zeeon.co.uk/gamehub/match-p ... leinster-h

[Big D]

Looking at the positives for Edinburgh:
- Healy seemed to settle well.
- Held them to 3 points for last 50-60min
- Won
- Bench had some impact.
- Scotland players who have had very little game time got minutes in their legs. Healy particularly has played very little rugby through the warm ups and RWC.

[Big D]

Finn and Redpath getting some fine reviews from the Bath game

Absolutely disgusting pass by Russell for De Glanville's walk-in:

{media][/media]

eta: ah, already posted, soz. Still, worth a re-run

It was a good game. I thought Redpath was excellent. Finn's offload for the first Bath score was about as good as you'll see and I thought he generally played pretty well. But he also made some sloppy errors. Will be interesting to see if Bath keep going with playing a big lump at 12.

Was it Finn that was charged down for Christies try?

[GrahamWa]

Yes

[Big D]

On this day 7 years ago seemed to be the start of the Munster/Glasgow spite. Earls red card then pumped Glasgow with 14.

[weegie01]

Showed a bit of baws to get back into it. Didn't think they looked too bad from 60 on, more aggressive. Boyle made a difference at the breakdown.

Huge difference. Edinburgh were losing the gainline battle all the way through the first half but Boyle made a couple of great turnovers that stopped any Dragons momentum. I thought the replacement props were much better than the Dragons replacements too.

Agreed (I’ve just watched the second half back now). Boyle made a huge difference at the breakdown. Generally Edinburgh in the last 20 were miles ahead of where they had been in the first 60. The Dragons still butchered a couple of decent chances though. Overall, a vastly unconvincing display from Embra, but it’s an away win and I’d have bitten your hand off for that at HT. Healy deservedly MoM.

Bizzarely, I was fairly confident throughout the match. For once, it wasn't that they did not look like they knew how to win the match, just that their execution was somewhere between poor and terrible.

There were far too many new combinations and unfamiliar players exemplified by Scott at 15, where he has never played before. To me they looked like they'd be OK once they'd settled and stopped making so many mistakes. The fringes of th eplayer pool has certainly been strengthened by that game.

[C T]

Glasgow showing some pretty decent skills so far, no points to show for it mind.

[Jock42]

Good strong finish there.

[Slick]

Looking at the positives for Edinburgh:
- Healy seemed to settle well.
- Held them to 3 points for last 50-60min
- Won
- Bench had some impact.
- Scotland players who have had very little game time got minutes in their legs. Healy particularly has played very little rugby through the warm ups and RWC.

The ST had Healy as playing almost god like, which seemed a bit strange given most of the comments on the game on here

[Tichtheid]

Glasgow are getting stiffed, Kebble is so dominant at the scrum the ref is calling it against him, saying he is driving across. His hips don't move out at all.

[Tichtheid]

At last he's seen what is actually happening in the scrum

[Yr Alban]

Can’t bear to watch another Scottish team capitulation to Leinster. Because it’s almost certainly what’s going to happen. It’s the equivalent of Hearts v Celtic today (well, apart from Leinster being an actual real Irish team, that is)

Edit: this was possibly the worst timed post in NPR history

[robmatic]

Looking at the positives for Edinburgh:
- Healy seemed to settle well.
- Held them to 3 points for last 50-60min
- Won
- Bench had some impact.
- Scotland players who have had very little game time got minutes in their legs. Healy particularly has played very little rugby through the warm ups and RWC.

The ST had Healy as playing almost god like, which seemed a bit strange given most of the comments on the game on here

It's the shock of seeing a game managing 10 at Edinburgh. Edinburgh were dire in the first half but Healy was at least making good decisions.

[Tichtheid]

5 - 0 win for Glasgow over Leinster.

Good.

[Yr Alban]

5 - 0 win for Glasgow over Leinster.

Good.

Agreed. I’m surprised and not a little delighted. As may have been clear from my previous poorly timed post, I fully expected them to lose.

OK, I’m sure it was a weakened Leinster side and a pretty strong Glasgow. But we keep getting told how alarmingly good Leinster’s reserves are, and the conveyor belt, and we’ve seen our teams beaten by second string Irish sides before, so I’ll take it.

[Slick]

5 - 0 win for Glasgow over Leinster.

Good.

Was it actually 5-0? Or is that bonus points?

Edit: just bothered my arse and checked, great result

[Dogbert]

Pretty decent way to spend a Sunday afternoon

Watching Glasgow beating Leinster ( albeit a Leinster shorn of a good number on first team players ) in a dry, but cold Scotstoun was vey satisfying.

Sure , a typical first season game, so plenty of stuff to work on

However ,as with all Franco’s teams, each player know their role, and the graft and effort were all there , even if some of the execution wasn’t.

It’s great watching some of the attacking rugby on display, The pop pass from the Sillerton loon that is Gregor Brown to Seba coming in at speed was pure classic Glasgow – reminiscent of Peter Horne/DTH, the timing and the speed make it a thing of beauty.

Probably the most pleasing was the defensive sets in both halves from Glasgow when Leinster were knocking on the door. I see Shuggie was awarded MOTM – and he certainly put in some defensive shift.

Great to see Horne Jnr get the 100 mark capping it with a fine try – nice also to see Franco acknowledging Scrappie’s performance.

(Nice to see the older warrior Sean Lamont in the crowd)

Onto Galway next , be interesting to see how Franco rotates the team for that one

[clydecloggie]

Watching it on TV, it struck me that Glasgow were playing like a mid-season team already - lots of combinations working decently, good connections across the pitch, clarity about the game plan - and that with a number of players on the pitch who did not do the pre-season with the Warriors. Bodes well for the next few games, I think they're ahead of the curve. Although teams like Connacht will have been able to train with almost their entire team as they did not have massive numbers at the WC.

[westport]

Mish is available for selection this weekend

[Tichtheid]

Mish is available for selection this weekend

Embra have Lions at home, Leinster away, Connacht at home and Bulls at home. If everyone is fit, bar those already named as not available, then I go as strong as possible for Lions and Bulls, mix it up for Connacht and take what coming in Dublin, resting the international players.

[Jock42]

Mish is available for selection this weekend

Embra have Lions at home, Leinster away, Connacht at home and Bulls at home. If everyone is fit, bar those already named as not available, then I go as strong as possible for Lions and Bulls, mix it up for Connacht and take what coming in Dublin, resting the international players.

I'm sure I read the Irish players are on a 3 week enforced stand down. I'd go all out v Leinster if that's the case.

[Tichtheid]

Mish is available for selection this weekend

Embra have Lions at home, Leinster away, Connacht at home and Bulls at home. If everyone is fit, bar those already named as not available, then I go as strong as possible for Lions and Bulls, mix it up for Connacht and take what coming in Dublin, resting the international players.

I'm sure I read the Irish players are on a 3 week enforced stand down. I'd go all out v Leinster if that's the case.

I can see the logic in that, however, given the last regular fixture this season is on the 1st of June ‘24, my preference would be to target the home games and a few winnable away ones in order to manage the players over such a long period

[clydecloggie]

Mish is available for selection this weekend

Embra have Lions at home, Leinster away, Connacht at home and Bulls at home. If everyone is fit, bar those already named as not available, then I go as strong as possible for Lions and Bulls, mix it up for Connacht and take what coming in Dublin, resting the international players.

I'm sure I read the Irish players are on a 3 week enforced stand down. I'd go all out v Leinster if that's the case.

I agree. Edinburgh's role in the URC essentially is to increase the chances of a Glasgow home semi by taking points off of top-4 hopefuls. They are duty-bound to go all out against Leinster and can then muck about against their fellow no-hopers, as per the last decade or so.

[topofthemoon]

Remaining permutations for Scotland Women ahead of the final round of WXV 2:

[Tichtheid]

In an announcement that will shock no one, Gilcho has been named as Embra's co-captain for the season alongside Ben Vellacott

[Slick]

Remaining permutations for Scotland Women ahead of the final round of WXV 2:

I don't really understand this competition, haven't we won all our games so shouldn't just winning against Japan be enough? Or are we not playing every team in the group so it will come down to points difference and we might not even play the winners?

Great idea to split the competition into these 3 groups, just not clear on the format even having watched the video.

[Tichtheid]

We’ve gone as full noise as we can

Edinburgh Rugby team to face Emirates Lions at Hive Stadium in the BKT United Rugby Championship
Saturday 28 October (kick-off 5pm) – live on Viaplay

15. Blair Kinghorn (134)
14. Ross McCann (1)
13. Mark Bennett (89)
12. Matt Currie (19)
11. Wes Goosen (11)
9. Ben Healy (1)
10. Ben Vellacott (39) CAPTAIN

1. Boan Venter (47)
2. Dave Cherry (72)
3. Javan Sebastian (1)
4. Glen Young (23)
5. Grant Gilchrist (188)
6. Luke Crosbie (85)
7. Hamish Watson (140)
8. Viliame Mata (116)

Replacements
16. Ewan Ashman*
17. Robin Hislop (20)
18. WP Nel (188)
19. Marshall Sykes (42)
20. Connor Boyle (33)
21. Charlie Shiel (56)
22. Cammy Scott (4)
23. Chris Dean (136)

Unavailable: Luan de Bruin (back), Darcy Graham (hip), Jake Henry (knee), Mikey Jones (ankle), James Lang (calf), Ben Muncaster (knee), Sam Skinner (knee), Scott Steele (hip), Nathan Sweeney (hamstring), Tim Swiel (ankle), Jamie Ritchie (shoulder)

Although playing Healy at scrum half will be quite something

[Tichtheid]

The Weegies have a strong side out too

Glasgow Warriors team to face Connacht at The Sportsground, Saturday 28 October, kick-off 3pm. You can watch the match live on Viaplay Sports, or follow all the action in our Live Match Centre at glasgowwarriors.org.

1 Oli Kebble (86)
2 Angus Fraser (4)
3 Zander Fagerson (129)
4 Scott Cummings (107)
5 Richie Gray (101)
6 Gregor Brown (13)
7 Sione Vailanu (20)
8 Henco Venter (1)

9 George Horne (100)
10 Tom Jordan (25)
11 Kyle Steyn (C) (66)
12 Stafford McDowall (58)
13 Huw Jones (60)
14 Kyle Rowe (0)
15 Josh McKay (28)

Replacements
16 Johnny Matthews (51)
17 Nathan McBeth (25)
18 Lucio Sordoni (16)
19 Greg Peterson (33)
20 Ally Miller (15)
21 Rory Darge (33)
22 Jamie Dobie (52)
23 Duncan Weir (134)

Unavailable for selection: Fraser Brown (knee), Facundo Cordero (ankle), Euan Ferrie (ankle), JP du Preez (knee), Murphy Walker (calf).

I think Rowe will be really good in this Glasgow side over the season

[Jock42]

I thought Mata might have got another week off. Still looking forward to seeing Scott at 10

Lot more grunt in that team, thought they were lacking any proper carriers last week.

[westport]

The wimin are destroying the Japanese at scrim and maul time

[SomersetJock]

The wimin are destroying the Japanese at scrim and maul time

Started watching at HT. Haven’t watched them play for a long time but they are certainly much improved on anytime I’ve watched them before.

[westport]

Good win 38-7

[westport]

The wimin are destroying the Japanese at scrim and maul time

Started watching at HT. Haven’t watched them play for a long time but they are certainly much improved on anytime I’ve watched them before.

Absolutely, they have come on leaps and bounds

[SomersetJock]

[quote=SomersetJock post_id=323407 time=<a href="tel:1698414069">1698414069</a> user_id=2145]
[quote=westport post_id=323405 time=<a href="tel:1698413390">1698413390</a> user_id=417]
The wimin are destroying the Japanese at scrim and maul time

Started watching at HT. Haven’t watched them play for a long time but they are certainly much improved on anytime I’ve watched them before.
[/quote]

Absolutely, they have come on leaps and bounds
[/quote]

The difference from when I last saw them is staggering, they looked completely clueless in the past and second best at every aspect of the game.

Completely opposite out there today !

well done to the ladies. I thoroughly enjoyed that !

[Slick]

The wimin are destroying the Japanese at scrim and maul time

Started watching at HT. Haven’t watched them play for a long time but they are certainly much improved on anytime I’ve watched them before.

Absolutely, they have come on leaps and bounds

Even in the last 2 years the improvement has been massive. It's a great day out to go and watch if you get the chance.

[Yr Alban]

Just turned on the Glasgow game, just in time to watch Connacht awarded possibly the most mystifying scrum penalty I’ve ever seen. Glasgow clearly have the stronger pack. Several scrums, shunting Connacht back. Win a free kick, decide to scrum again. Connacht scrum disintegrates. Ref blows - penalty Connacht.

[robmatic]

Just turned on the Glasgow game, just in time to watch Connacht awarded possibly the most mystifying scrum penalty I’ve ever seen. Glasgow clearly have the stronger pack. Several scrums, shunting Connacht back. Win a free kick, decide to scrum again. Connacht scrum disintegrates. Ref blows - penalty Connacht.

The ref also missed a really blatant deliberate knock on by Glasgow so we can't complain too much.

[Yr Alban]

Glasgow really do seem to be doing everything they can to lose this game.

[TheNatalShark]

Don't know if just flow of game in second half since I started watching, but ref seems to be riding Weegies hard