Jock42 wrote: Wed Jul 31, 2024 11:45 am
inactionman wrote: Wed Jul 31, 2024 11:26 am
Jock42 wrote: Wed Jul 31, 2024 11:20 am
These cunts should be nowhere near the military, it's not the military problem to solve. Poor recruitment isn't just down to capita, retention is probably a bigger issue. I'd not want some cunt that is a conscript in combat with me, fuck that!! There's also not enough NCOs to train them and not enough training estates either. It's a non starter that would erode our forces.
Fair enough.
Would you wonder whether their actions are to do with frustration, senses of powerlessness and a huge helping of ignorance, and that exposing them to something like national service might be of some use? We're not talking of putting them on front lines, we're not Russia.
Or bang them up, ostracise them, make them unemployable and then cross fingers that they stop being arseholes?
Did nobody who's previously done national service commit crime?
When the next conflict rolls around and units are doing back to back tours how long will it be until these men and women are augmenting regular units? Where are they being based? What are they being paid? What roles are they fulfilling? Why is it the military's role to sort out society's problem? What happens when they go AWOL?
I'm a bit concerned you're saying these are all - to a man - inherently and irredeemably bad people. I think they're mainly people who have been fed bullshit their entire lives and don't have the wherewithal to see through it. I'm sure there are a fair few psychopaths, and far too many dogwhistlers who exploit these people's misconceptions and prejudice. Removing some of these influenced people from an environment where all they hear are dogwhistles would seem a good step.
I'd also prefer that national service - if we had it - was built more on the Isreali model. It's not necessarily a direct military thing, you could go into a whole range of disciplines (there is also something called Sherut Leumi where people can go to work at schools, hospitals etc but that is meant more for objectors to military service). I agree you'd not want a modern army (well, any army, but especially a small, professional army) built upon and around reluctant people who are only there as it was forced on them - the miltiary gets proposed a lot in these conversations for obvious reasons but it's not the only option. Have them landscaping public parks for all I really care, but at least something that is contributing.
Anyway all a digression - we need to do something about these people, and I can't see ostracising them socially doing much more then entrenching their idiocy.